{"id":"arxiv:2308.08708","title":"Consciousness in Artificial Intelligence: Insights from the Science of Consciousness","date":"2023-08-17","section":"AI safety and consciousness","quality":-0.0297,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/","source_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08708","text_available":true,"authors":["Patrick Butlin","Robert Long","Eric Elmoznino","Yoshua Bengio"],"outgoing":[{"source":"arxiv:2308.08708","target":"arxiv:2210.08340","evidence":"id","id":"arxiv:2210.08340","title":"Toward Next-Generation Artificial Intelligence: Catalyzing the NeuroAI Revolution","url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/7e67e1f87352a71473f443d1e0ca0682eb8496db1682a89345b3fd54126e2d35/"},{"source":"arxiv:2308.08708","target":"arxiv:2303.07103","evidence":"title","id":"arxiv:2303.07103","title":"Could a Large Language Model be Conscious?","url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/066af7a709204ed7ece7130b13781997ec7b3a9be7f1881c6fc2bd9aa00cea33/"}],"incoming":[{"source":"arxiv:2311.02462","target":"arxiv:2308.08708","evidence":"id","id":"arxiv:2311.02462","title":"Levels of AGI for Operationalizing Progress on the Path to AGI","url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/288b98572ecf9c0b81bcb6d0c89b523e3b71a5b3623301b9e24536f615a07bca/"},{"source":"arxiv:2503.16348","target":"arxiv:2308.08708","evidence":"id","id":"arxiv:2503.16348","title":"Palatable Conceptions of Disembodied Being","url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/00f41876b2b8852e1d5e080ecee9244ad7ccd7501df38c0527112912d3b462cf/"}],"text_parts":[{"start":0,"end":15269,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-1.html"},{"start":15269,"end":30995,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-2.html"},{"start":30995,"end":46027,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-3.html"},{"start":46027,"end":61523,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-4.html"},{"start":61523,"end":77403,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-5.html"},{"start":77403,"end":93023,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-6.html"},{"start":93023,"end":108148,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-7.html"},{"start":108148,"end":123164,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-8.html"},{"start":123164,"end":139057,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-9.html"},{"start":139057,"end":154001,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-10.html"},{"start":154001,"end":169577,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-11.html"},{"start":169577,"end":185540,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-12.html"},{"start":185540,"end":201302,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-13.html"},{"start":201302,"end":204217,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-14.html"}],"contents":[{"title":"1 Introduction","offset":12159,"level":2,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-1.html#text"},{"title":"1.1 Terminology","offset":14631,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-1.html#text"},{"title":"1.2 Methods and Assumptions","offset":22115,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-2.html#text"},{"title":"1.2.1 Computational functionalism","offset":25241,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-2.html#text"},{"title":"1.2.2 Scientific theories of consciousness","offset":30946,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-2.html#text"},{"title":"1.2.3 Theory-heavy approach","offset":37339,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-3.html#text"},{"title":"2 Scientific Theories of Consciousness","offset":44324,"level":2,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-3.html#text"},{"title":"2.1 Recurrent Processing Theory","offset":47010,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-4.html#text"},{"title":"2.1.1 Introduction to recurrent processing theory","offset":47047,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-4.html#text"},{"title":"2.1.2 Evidence for recurrent processing theory","offset":48833,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-4.html#text"},{"title":"2.1.3 Indicators from recurrent processing theory","offset":50955,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-4.html#text"},{"title":"2.2 Global Workspace Theory","offset":56844,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-4.html#text"},{"title":"2.2.1 Introduction to global workspace theory","offset":56877,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-4.html#text"},{"title":"2.2.2 Evidence for global workspace theory","offset":60329,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-4.html#text"},{"title":"2.2.3 Indicators from global workspace theory","offset":63169,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-5.html#text"},{"title":"2.3 Higher-Order Theories","offset":72045,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-5.html#text"},{"title":"2.3.1 Introduction to higher-order theories","offset":72076,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-5.html#text"},{"title":"2.3.2 Computational HOTs and GWT","offset":76437,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-5.html#text"},{"title":"2.3.3 Indicators from computational HOTs","offset":79762,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-6.html#text"},{"title":"2.4 Other Theories and Conditions","offset":86132,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-6.html#text"},{"title":"2.4.1 Attention Schema Theory","offset":88072,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-6.html#text"},{"title":"2.4.2 Predictive Processing","offset":91036,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-6.html#text"},{"title":"2.4.3 Midbrain Theory","offset":93516,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-7.html#text"},{"title":"2.4.4 Unlimited Associative Learning","offset":95653,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-7.html#text"},{"title":"2.4.5 Agency and Embodiment","offset":101297,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-7.html#text"},{"title":"2.4.5(a) Agency","offset":102996,"level":2,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-7.html#text"},{"title":"2.4.5(b) Embodiment","offset":112712,"level":2,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-8.html#text"},{"title":"2.4.5(c) Agency and embodiment indicators","offset":121242,"level":2,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-8.html#text"},{"title":"2.4.6 Time and Recurrence","offset":125711,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-9.html#text"},{"title":"2.5 Indicators of Consciousness","offset":129178,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-9.html#text"},{"title":"3 Consciousness in AI","offset":130908,"level":2,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-9.html#text"},{"title":"3.1 Implementing Indicator Properties in AI","offset":134248,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-9.html#text"},{"title":"3.1.1 Implementing RPT and PP","offset":134297,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-9.html#text"},{"title":"3.1.2 Implementing GWT","offset":139028,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-9.html#text"},{"title":"3.1.3 Implementing PRM","offset":146930,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-10.html#text"},{"title":"3.1.4 Implementing AST","offset":160493,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-11.html#text"},{"title":"3.1.5 Implementing agency and embodiment","offset":163389,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-11.html#text"},{"title":"3.2 Case Studies of Current Systems","offset":168265,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-11.html#text"},{"title":"3.2.1 Case studies for GWT","offset":168306,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-11.html#text"},{"title":"3.2.2 Case studies for embodied agency","offset":175496,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-12.html#text"},{"title":"4 Implications","offset":184342,"level":2,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-12.html#text"},{"title":"4.1 Attributing Consciousness to AI","offset":184946,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-12.html#text"},{"title":"4.1.1 Under-attributing consciousness to AI","offset":185490,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-12.html#text"},{"title":"4.1.2 Over-attributing consciousness to AI","offset":188405,"level":4,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-13.html#text"},{"title":"4.2 Consciousness and Capabilities","offset":193635,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-13.html#text"},{"title":"4.3 Recommendations","offset":200605,"level":3,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-13.html#text"},{"title":"Glossary","offset":204204,"level":2,"url":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/part-14.html#text"}],"text_code_points":204217,"source_markdown":"https://vinnik-dmitry07.github.io/favorite-papers/agents/papers/e7d3e0c10e0ae2d2d2d5a65d4df9b37db6e65fe2ef82355a9235738ff15f907e/source.md"}